Key Takeaways
- Coinbase urged the CFTC to classify prediction market event contracts as swaps, establishing exclusive federal oversight of contracts tied to sports, politics, culture, weather, and other events.
- Senate Democrats accused CFTC Chairman Michael Selig of misleading Congress and demanded withdrawal of his directive requiring exchanges to eliminate state-level geoblocks.
- Coinbase distinguished prediction markets from traditional gambling, supporting separate rules excluding casino-style products from swaps.
CFTC’s Prediction Market Push Sparks Political Backlash
Cryptocurrency exchange Coinbase is urging regulators to adopt a rule explicitly classifying event-based prediction contracts as swaps, backing a proposal by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) that has drawn sharp criticism from Senate Democrats who accuse the agency’s chairman of misleading Congress.
In a formal comment letter to the CFTC, Coinbase supported the agency’s proposal to clarify that event contracts—including those tied to sports, politics, culture, and weather—fall under the Commodity Exchange Act’s broad definition of a swap and the CFTC’s exclusive federal jurisdiction.
The letter comes amid a jurisdictional battle involving prediction market operators, federal regulators, and state and tribal gaming authorities. State regulators and Native American tribes have sought to block sports-related event contracts as illegal gambling, resulting in a patchwork of conflicting federal court rulings and state-level injunctions.
The dispute escalated on Capitol Hill when Sen. Adam Schiff, D-Calif., accused CFTC Chairman Michael Selig of “blatantly” deceiving him and the Senate Agriculture Committee.
During his 2025 confirmation process, Selig pledged to remain a “blank slate” and defer to federal courts on whether sports contracts constitute gambling. Since taking office, however, Selig—currently the agency’s sole Senate-confirmed commissioner—has intervened in court battles to assert exclusive federal jurisdiction. He also issued a Nov. 5 directive giving exchanges 30 days to remove state-by-state geographic restrictions, known as “geoblocks.”
Schiff and eight other Democratic senators have demanded that the CFTC withdraw the directive, arguing that it effectively instructs exchanges to violate existing court orders.
In its comment letter, Coinbase argued that finalizing the swap definition is necessary to resolve the legal uncertainty created by state enforcement actions and conflicting court decisions.
“Those disputes do not change the best reading of the statute,” wrote Julia Hueckel, Coinbase’s director of regulatory policy, and David Shafer, director and associate general counsel for institutional legal. “But they do create real uncertainty for exchanges, intermediaries, customers, and courts.”
According to Coinbase, the conflicting legal landscape imposes significant costs on businesses, erodes customer goodwill, fragments market depth and liquidity, and hampers traders’ ability to hedge economic risks.
Under the Commodity Exchange Act, a swap includes contracts whose payments depend on an event or contingency associated with a “potential financial, economic, or commercial consequence.” Coinbase argued that sports, political, cultural, and weather events all carry measurable commercial exposure, affecting sectors ranging from agriculture and energy to media rights, ticketing, tourism, and hospitality.
Coinbase Draws Line Between Prediction Markets and Gambling
The company also drew a distinction between exchange-traded event contracts and traditional sportsbooks or casinos. Unlike casinos, which take the opposite side of customers’ wagers, prediction market exchanges operate as neutral marketplaces that match buyers and sellers at market-clearing prices, according to the letter.
Coinbase said it also supports a separate CFTC effort to confirm that traditional casino-style gambling products are not swaps, arguing that the two rules would establish a “workable line” between federal derivatives markets and state-regulated gambling.
Coinbase urged the CFTC to ensure that the rule’s listed categories of sports, politics, culture, and weather remain illustrative rather than exhaustive. A rigid list, the company warned, could quickly become outdated and stifle innovation in emerging markets involving digital assets, blockchain events, and technological or scientific milestones.
The company also recommended that the final rule affirm that event contracts already qualify as swaps under existing law, describing the proposed regulation as providing additional “belt and suspenders” clarity.
Coinbase further argued that the benefits of establishing a uniform national regulatory framework outweigh the costs, even under the assumption that states previously held regulatory authority over such contracts.
The exchange currently offers prediction markets through its partnership with Kalshi, but a Bloomberg report on Thursday citing a source familiar with its plans said that Coinbase plans to offer its own in-house markets in the first half of 2027.